Offtackle

Football news for every down

The Notebook: Tennessee Built a Roster of People Who Already Know How to Play the Way They Want to Play

Eleven of fourteen additions have prior ties to Saleh, Daboll, or Carthon. The organizational philosophy is on the record. And Atlanta's story was always about a Penix ACL, not a competition.

The most interesting organization in the AFC this week is not Pittsburgh, which still has its quarterback question open. It is Tennessee.

Here is what Robert Saleh and general manager Ran Carthon did in the first day of free agency. They spent somewhere between $270 and $275 million. They signed pass rusher John Franklin-Myers to three years and $63 million. They acquired edge rusher Jermaine Johnson II from the Jets in a trade, sending nose tackle T'Vondre Sweat to New York. They signed wide receiver Wan'Dale Robinson to four years and $78 million. They added Mitchell Trubisky as the backup quarterback behind Cam Ward. And by the end of the day, eleven of the fourteen additions they had made had prior connections to Saleh, to Carthon, or to offensive coordinator Brian Daboll.

I want to say that number again. Eleven of fourteen.

There is a philosophy embedded in that statistic that does not get discussed enough when teams rebuild. What Saleh and Carthon are doing is not simply acquiring talented players. They are building a roster of players who already know how to be the kind of players they want. Johnson played for Saleh in New York. Franklin-Myers played for Saleh in New York. Robinson played for Daboll in New York, when Daboll was the Giants' head coach and drafted Robinson sixteenth overall in 2022. The shorthand these players bring into the building — the shared language of what a scheme requires, the willingness to do the things that do not show up in statistics, the understanding of how a staff communicates — has value that you cannot quantify on a transaction wire.

The Robinson signing tells you the most about how the staff is thinking. He had 92 receptions and 1,014 yards in 2025, a career year. He goes to Tennessee at four years and $78 million and immediately gives Cam Ward a second option alongside a returning Calvin Ridley. The Daboll connection is real and directly relevant — Robinson's best football in New York came when the offense was structured around quick decisions and predetermined reads. That is the style Daboll runs. Tennessee hired Daboll to run it again. You do not have to project how Robinson and Daboll operate together. You already know.

The question the offseason leaves open is whether the roster Tennessee has assembled is ready to compete in the AFC in 2026 or whether this is a one-year building block. Saleh went 3-14 in his first season in New York. Carthon came from a Kansas City organization that built through patience. The spending suggests urgency. The philosophy — players who know you, a scheme with an established language — suggests they believe they can compress the development timeline.

I think they are right to try. The AFC South is more open than it has been in several years. Houston has the quarterback. Jacksonville is a year deeper under Liam Coen. Indianapolis is steady. What Tennessee is betting is that the organizational cohesion they are building this offseason pays dividends faster than the league expects.

We will see if the money was right and if the players were the right ones. But the philosophy behind the spending is sound. You want to know that the players you are adding understand how to play the way you want to play. Saleh and Carthon built a roster of players who already do.


The Atlanta situation deserves a correction and a clarification, and I want to provide both plainly.

When the Tua Tagovailoa signing was announced, it was framed publicly as a competition for Michael Penix Jr.'s starting job. GM Ian Cunningham used the word compete. I wrote about what that word does inside a building and how Kevin Stefanski would need to manage the dynamic. Multiple people around the league read the signing the same way.

The clarification, which has emerged this week: Penix tore his ACL. He is not available to compete in the spring or potentially into the regular season. Tua is not a competitor for Penix's job. He is a bridge while the organization waits for its franchise quarterback to return from a significant injury. The signing at a minimum contract with the Dolphins absorbing $54 million of Tagovailoa's salary makes complete sense viewed through that lens.

This changes the story in almost every respect. Atlanta did not acquire a veteran quarterback to challenge a first-round pick for his job. They acquired a quarterback to protect the organization from a potentially catastrophic scenario — a season without their starter and no legitimate replacement. Whether Tua can hold the position at a functional level while Penix recovers is the question. His talent is not in doubt. His durability record makes that question genuine.

Stefanski has also added wide receiver Jahan Dotson from Philadelphia at two years and up to $17 million. Dotson ran a 4.43 at the combine when he was drafted and provides the outside speed threat the offense needs while Penix is out. The construction is deliberate: protect the quarterback position, add a field-stretcher to give Tua the kind of single-coverage shot he operates well with. The front office is managing a difficult situation with more organizational clarity than the initial framing suggested.


Aaron Rodgers said something this week that is going to stay with me.

Someone asked him whether Pittsburgh had given him a deadline to decide. He said: "There hasn't been a deadline set to me." That is a very precise answer to a very direct question. He did not say he is coming back. He did not say he is retiring. He said the Pittsburgh organization has not set a timeline.

Jamel Dean, the cornerback Pittsburgh just signed from Tampa Bay, told reporters he expects Rodgers back. Head coach Mike McCarthy and general manager Omar Khan have publicly said they want Rodgers back. The Steelers are, by multiple accounts, keeping him informed of every roster move they make.

That is an organization behaving as though the quarterback is coming. It is not yet an organization that has confirmed the quarterback is coming. The difference matters for everyone on the roster who is trying to understand what this offense will actually ask of them in August.


One more item, and I want to get it right.

The Georgia Bulldogs opened spring practice today, and I want to say something specific about what Gunner Stockton is doing that I think gets missed in the preseason conversation about him.

Stockton finished seventh in Heisman voting last season. He is entering his second full year as the starter with eight defensive starters back on his own team and a defensive line that just added Amaris Williams from Auburn through the portal. He is preparing, this spring, against the best defense he has faced in practice since he arrived in Athens.

The evaluation community still has questions about Stockton in pure passing situations — when the defensive design removes the run option and forces the quarterback to generate on his own. Those questions are real and will not be settled in March. What will be settled, gradually, is whether Stockton's command of the system and the poise he has shown in big games translates to his first spring as the undisputed number one.

He has already shown it can. I am interested to see what he does with a full spring of first-team work and no uncertainty about his standing in the building.

Offtackle Staff Writers

← Back to today's edition